Even Open-Label Placebos Work – if They Are Explained

26.09.2017, 11:19 | Wissenschaft | Autor: | Jetzt kommentieren


For some medical complaints, open-label placebos work just as well as deceptive ones. As psychologists from the University of Basel and Harvard Medical School report in the journal Pain, the accompanying rationale plays an important role when administering a placebo.

The successful treatment of certain physical and psychological complaints can be explained to a significant extent by the placebo effect. The crucial question in this matter is how this effect can be harnessed without deceiving the patients. Recent empirical studies have shown that placebos administered openly have clinically significant effects on physical complaints such as chronic back pain, irritable bowel syndrome, episodic migraine and rhinitis.

Cream for pain relief

For the first time, researchers from the University of Basel, along with colleagues from Harvard Medical School, have compared the effects of administering open-label and deceptive placebos. The team conducted an experimental study with 160 healthy volunteers who were exposed to increasing heat on their forearm via a heating plate. The participants were asked to manually stop the temperature rise as soon as they could no longer stand the heat. After that, they were given a cream to relieve the pain.

Some of the participants were deceived during the experiment: they were told that they were given a pain relief cream with the active ingredient lidocaine, although it was actually a placebo. Other participants received a cream that was clearly labeled as a placebo; they were also given fifteen minutes of explanations about the placebo effect, its occurrence and its effect mechanisms. A third group received an open-label placebo without any further explanation.

The subjects of the first two groups reported a significant decrease in pain intensity and unpleasantness after the experiment. “The previous assumption that placebos only work when they are administered by deception needs to be reconsidered,” says Dr. Cosima Locher, a member of the University of Basel’s Faculty of Psychology and first author of the study.

Stronger pain when no rationale is given

When detailed explanations of the placebo effect were absent – as in the third group – the subjects reported significantly more intense and unpleasant pain. This suggests the crucial role of the accompanying rationale and communication when administering a placebo; the researchers speak of a narrative. The ethically problematic aspect of placebos, the deception, thus does not appear all that different from a transparent and convincing narrative. “Openly administering a placebo offers new possibilities for using the placebo effect in an ethically justifiable way,” says co-author Professor Jens Gaab, Head of the Division of Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy at the University of Basel.

Original article

Cosima Locher, Antje Frey Nascimento, Irving Kirsch, Joe Kossowsky, Andrea Meyer, Jens Gaab
Is the rationale more important than deception? A randomized controlled trial of open-label placebo analgesia
PAIN (2017), doi: 10.1097/j.pain.0000000000001012

Further information

Dr. Cosima Locher, University of Basel, Faculty of Psychology, Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, tel. +41 61 207 03 85, email: cosima.locher@unibas.ch

Weitere Informationen:
- https://www.unibas.ch/en/News-Events/News/Uni-Research/Even-Open-Label-Placebos-Work---if-They-Are-Explained.html

Quelle: idw


Weitere Nachrichten zum Thema
  • BildMechanism to Repair Clumped Proteins Explained (20.11.2012, 20:10)
    Clumped proteins can be dissolved with the aid of cellular repair systems – a process of critical importance for cell survival especially under conditions of stress. Heidelberg researchers have now decrypted the fundamental mechanism for...
  • BildSOFI Work in Progress (28.11.2011, 15:10)
    Spaltung der Arbeitswelt – Prekarität für alle? Konzepte und Befunde zu neuen Konturen der ArbeitsgesellschaftEinladung zur Konferenz vom 1. bis 2. Februar 2012 in der Paulinerkirche GöttingenLassen sich neue Konturen der Arbeitsgesellschaft...
  • BildProtection from severe malaria explained (18.11.2011, 12:10)
    Defective hemoglobin prevents the establishment of an important transport system of the malaria parasite in infected blood cells/Heidelberg researchers’ results published in ScienceWhy do people with a hereditary mutation of the red blood pigment...
  • BildYes, we are open. (08.08.2011, 22:10)
    Einblicke in die Studiengänge Marketingkommunikation und Kommunikationsdesign an der design akademie berlinWer seine berufliche Zukunft in der Design-, Kommunikations- oder Marketingbranche sieht, sollte am 18. August von 10 bis 16 Uhr beim Open...
  • BildRationalisation measures are the main cause of poor work environment (14.12.2010, 19:00)
    Managers in the private and public sectors must consider work environment when rationalising production to obtain sustainable systems. A research study published in the journal Applied Ergonomics reveals that rationalisation measures often have a...
  • BildWie Placebos wirken (19.10.2010, 15:00)
    Der Marburger Psychologie-Professor Dr. Winfried Rief ist Sprecher einer neuen Forschungsgruppe, die Placebo- und Nocebo-Effekte untersucht. Das hat der Senat der Deutschen Forschungsgemeinschaft entschieden, die das Vorhaben finanziell fördert....
  • BildMethane in coastal seas´ sediments: Are they an additional peril for global climate or in a stable e (26.07.2010, 18:00)
    Research Vessel Maria S. Merian is launching for a research cruise dedicated to potential sources of methane in the Baltic Sea from July 31 to August 22, 2010.An international group of marine chemists, microbiologists and geologists coordi-nated...
  • BildWarum Placebos wirken können (14.11.2008, 11:00)
    Die VolkswagenStiftung fördert Forschung zum Placebo-Effekt mit rund 700.000 EuroHeilung durch Einbildung? Noch vor wenigen Jahren reagierten Mediziner skeptisch, wenn vom Placebo-Effekt die Rede war. Heute ist klar, dass man tatsächlich Leiden...
  • BildIntegration@Work (10.10.2008, 12:00)
    Entscheidungsträger sollen Weg für barrierefreie IT am Arbeitsplatz ebnen.Zur Tagung "Integration@Work - barrierefreie Informationstechnik am Arbeitsplatz" lädt das Aktionsbündnis für barrierefreie Informationstechnik (AbI) am Mittwoch, 26....
  • BildWeniger Stromverbrauch mit Standby-Label? (28.09.2005, 18:00)
    Allein im Jahr 2004 verschleuderten elektrische Geräte in deutschen Haushalten und Büros rund 18 Milliarden Kilowattstunden Strom im Standby-Zustand. Dies entspricht fast der gesamten Stromerzeugung aus Windenergie in Deutschland. Bei vielen...

Ähnliche Themen in den JuraForen


Kommentar schreiben

59 - Ei,ns =

Bisherige Kommentare zur Nachricht (0)

(Keine Kommentare vorhanden)



Fragen Sie einen Anwalt!
Anwälte sind gerade online.
Schnelle Antwort auf Ihre Rechtsfrage.

JuraForum-Newsletter

Kostenlose aktuelle Urteile und Rechtstipps per E-Mail:

Top 10 Orte in der Anwaltssuche

JuraForum-Suche

Durchsuchen Sie hier JuraForum.de nach bestimmten Begriffen:

© 2003-2017 JuraForum.de — Alle Rechte vorbehalten. Keine Vervielfältigung, Verbreitung oder Nutzung für kommerzielle Zwecke.